Understand Certificates of Shares and Significant Interest

Certificates of shares are an essential tool for companies that want to engage and motivate their employees. They provide employees with a unique opportunity to participate economically in the company without the full rights and responsibilities of a shareholder. This financial instrument creates a win-win situation for both employers and employees. In this comprehensive article, we delve deeply into the world of certificates of shares with significant interest. We examine what they are, how they function, and what advantages and disadvantages they bring for all involved parties.

What Are Certificates of Shares?

Certificates of shares are complex financial instruments that represent the economic rights of shares, without granting full governance rights. These certificates are issued by a specially established administration office, which possesses and manages the actual shares on behalf of the certificate holders. The concept of certificates of shares arose to create a balance between employee participation and the retention of governance within the company. By issuing certificates, companies can allow their employees to share in the financial successes of the business without complicating the decision-making structure. This makes certificates of shares an attractive option for companies that want to reward and retain their employees while at the same time maintaining strategic control.

How Do Certificates of Shares Work?

The process of issuing and managing certificates of shares operates through a carefully set up structure. First, the company issues shares to a specially established administration office, usually in the form of a foundation. This administration office acts as an intermediary and manages the shares on behalf of the certificate holders. The administration office then issues certificates of these shares to employees. These certificates represent the economic rights of the underlying shares, such as the right to dividends and possible appreciation in value. However, the crucial difference is that employees do not have voting rights in the shareholders' meeting. This voting right remains with the administration office, which operates according to pre-established guidelines. This construct ensures that employees can financially benefit from the growth of the company, while governance remains concentrated among a smaller group of directors or shareholders.

Free decision aid

There are 6 ways to let employees share in the growth of the company.

Which form suits your company?

Take the decision aid

Benefits for Employees

Certificates of shares provide employees with a range of attractive benefits that can strengthen their engagement and loyalty to the company. First, they offer economic participation, allowing employees to directly benefit from the financial growth and profits of the business. This creates a sense of co-ownership and can lead to increased motivation and productivity. Second, certificates serve as a powerful reward and motivation tool, enabling companies to attract and retain top talent in a competitive labor market. Additionally, employees with certificates bear less risk than full shareholders, as they do not carry the full liabilities and risks of shareholding. This makes it a safer way for employees to invest in the company they work for. Furthermore, certificates of shares can also provide tax benefits, depending on the specific structure and applicable tax legislation. Finally, certificates offer employees insights into the financial performance of the company, which can lead to a better understanding of corporate strategies and objectives.

Significant Interest: What Does It Mean?

In Dutch tax legislation, the concept of 'significant interest' plays an important role in the taxation of shares and certificates of shares. There is a significant interest when a shareholder owns at least 5% of the shares in a company. This criterion applies to both ordinary shares and certificates of shares. The concept of significant interest is crucial because it has specific tax implications, particularly the taxation in box 2 of income tax. This tax treatment can have significant implications for the net earnings that certificate holders receive from their participation in the company. Therefore, it is essential for both companies and employees to understand the tax aspects of certificates of shares and take them into account in their financial planning.

Criteria for Significant Interest

The criteria for determining a significant interest are precisely defined in Dutch tax legislation. A shareholder has a significant interest if one of the following conditions is met:

1. The shareholder directly or indirectly owns at least 5% of the shares in a company.
2. The shareholder owns profit-sharing certificates that entitle them to at least 5% of the annual profit of the company.
3. The shareholder owns share options that grant them the right to acquire at least 5% of the shares in the company.
4. The shareholder owns a combination of the above rights that together exceed the 5% threshold.
5. The shareholder belongs to a group of connected persons (for example, family members) who collectively meet one of the above criteria.

It is important to note that these criteria apply not only to direct ownership but also to indirect ownership through other companies or structures. Moreover, significant interest can also arise due to certain family relationships, where the interests of close family members can be aggregated.

Tax Benefits and Consequences

The tax treatment of certificates of shares with significant interest can offer substantial advantages compared to other forms of remuneration. Unlike regular income, which is taxed in box 1 of income tax, income from a significant interest falls under taxation in box 2. The rate in box 2 is generally lower than the highest brackets in box 1, which can result in a lower tax burden for the certificate holder. Moreover, box 2 taxation provides opportunities for tax deferral, as the appreciation of the certificates is only taxed upon sale or dividend payment. This can lead to considerable long-term tax advantages. However, it is crucial to emphasize that tax legislation is complex and frequently changing. Certificate holders should therefore always seek current tax advice to assess their specific situation. Additionally, there can also be disadvantages, such as a more limited possibility of loss offsetting compared to box 1 income.

Significant Interest Without 5% Profit Right

Sometimes, companies and employees want to structure their interest in such a way that the ownership falls into box 2, thereby establishing a significant interest. However, it is rare for an employer to want to give an employee more than 5% of the shares. To still achieve box 2 status, we can issue non-profit shares in combination with a STAK. This way, the employee does not receive more voting rights or profit rights, yet the ownership qualifies under box 2.

Conclusion

Certificates of shares represent a powerful and versatile instrument for companies striving for increased employee participation and motivation. They offer a unique balance between sharing economic benefits with employees and retaining strategic control within the company. By allowing employees to directly profit from the growth and success of the business, certificates of shares create a strong link between individual performance and corporate results.

Implementing a certificates program requires careful planning and expertise in legal, tax, and financial areas. Companies must weigh the pros and cons carefully and design a structure that fits their specific situation and objectives. Transparency, clear communication, and ongoing education are essential for the success of the program.

While there are challenges, such as the complexity of the structure and potential tax changes, the benefits often outweigh the disadvantages. Certificates of shares can lead to a more engaged and motivated workforce, which in turn can result in increased productivity, innovation, and ultimately business success.

For companies looking for ways to bind and reward their employees, while simultaneously retaining control over key decisions, certificates of shares provide an attractive solution. With the right implementation and management, they can create a win-win situation for both the company and its employees, leading to sustainable growth and success in the long term.