Options as Employee Participation: Advantages, Disadvantages, and Alternatives

Employee participation is a way for employees to share in the success of a company. It means that employees become a partial owner of the company they work for. This can occur in various forms, such as through shares or options. More and more companies are choosing this approach because it motivates employees and binds them to the company. In this article, we will explore options as a form of employee participation. We will discuss the pros and cons and compare it with other forms.

What are Stock Options?

Stock options grant employees the right to purchase shares in the future at a predetermined price. This price is known as the exercise price. Employees typically receive the options as part of their compensation. They can only use the options after a certain period, usually after a few years. If the stock price is higher than the exercise price at that time, employees make a profit. They buy the shares at a lower price than the market price. However, the employee must pay income tax on the difference between the purchase price and the market price.

Advantages of Options as Employee Participation

Options can be a significant motivator for employees. They feel more involved in the company because they benefit from its success. This can lead to harder work and better performance. Companies can use options to attract and retain good employees more easily, especially in sectors where there is high competition for talent, such as in the tech industry. For employees, it is rewarding to benefit from the company's growth. If the company is successful, they can earn substantial money from their options. Companies also have tax benefits when granting options, as they can often deduct the costs for taxation.

Free decision aid

There are 6 ways to let employees share in the growth of the company.

Which form suits your company?

Take the decision aid

Disadvantages of Options as Employee Participation

For employers, the main disadvantage is that payments to employees are not deductible from profits, unlike in a SAR plan. For employees, there is also a risk. If the stock price falls below the exercise price, the options become worthless. This situation is referred to as being 'underwater'. This can be demotivating for employees. They may have expected extra income but end up with nothing.

Comparison with Other Forms of Employee Participation

SAR (Stock Appreciation Rights) Plans

A SAR is similar to options, but employees do not receive actual shares. They only receive the difference between the exercise price and the higher market price as payment. This is easier for the company because no actual shares are issued. The downside is that employees do not become real shareholders, so they may feel less involved in the company.

Shares

With shares, employees become direct co-owners of the company. They have all the rights of a shareholder, such as voting rights and the right to dividends. The advantage is that employees benefit directly when the company does well. The disadvantage is that employees also take on risk immediately if things go poorly. With options, employees only lose potential profits and not their own money.

Certificates of Shares

Certificates are a middle ground. Employees receive the economic rights of shares, such as dividends, but do not get voting rights. This can be useful for companies that want to retain decision-making power within a small group. The downside is that employees may feel less involved because they cannot participate in decision-making.

Implementing an Option Plan

Setting up an option plan requires careful planning. First, the company must decide how many options to issue and to whom. Then, they need to determine the terms, such as the exercise price and waiting period. It is important to seek legal and tax advice, as the rules surrounding options can be complex. Good communication with employees is crucial. They must understand how the options work and what the risks are. It may help to organize an information session or create a clear guide.

Conclusion

Options as a form of employee participation have clear advantages. They can motivate employees and bind them to the company. They can also lead to significant financial rewards when the company is doing well. However, there are also disadvantages, such as complexity and risks for employees. Companies must carefully consider whether options fit their situation. They can also look at alternatives such as SARs, shares, or certificates. The most important thing is that the chosen form aligns with the company's goals and the needs of the employees.

Veelgestelde vragen