Certificates of Shares and Stock Appreciation Rights (SAR Scheme): What You Need to Know

Introduction

Certificates of shares and Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs) are two important financial instruments that companies can use to reward and motivate employees. In this blog post, we will discuss these two instruments in detail, analyze their advantages and disadvantages, and explain how they differ from each other. Whether you are a business owner considering implementing these options or an employee being offered these rewards, this guide will help you make an informed decision.

What Are Certificates of Shares?

Free decision aid

There are 6 ways to let employees share in the growth of the company.

Which form suits your company?

Take the decision aid

Definition and Explanation

Certificates of shares are financial instruments that represent an interest in a company without the associated voting rights that regular shares have. This means that the holder of the certificate can financially benefit from the company's performance without directly influencing business decisions. For example, the owner of the certificates is not invited to the general shareholders' meeting (AVA). However, if dividends are paid, the certificate owner will receive them. Read more about certificates on this page.

Advantages of Certificates of Shares

• Retention of Control: Companies can attract additional capital without having to give up voting rights. This helps the original shareholders to maintain control over the company.
• Employee Participation: Employees can financially benefit from the company's growth, which can increase their motivation and engagement.

Disadvantages of Certificates of Shares

• Tax and Legal Complications: There may be complex tax regulations and legal issues when issuing certificates of shares.
• Less Direct Influence: Employees do not have voting rights, limiting their influence on business decisions.

More information about certificates of shares can be found on this page.

What Are Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs)?

Definition and Explanation

Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs) are a form of employee participation in which the employee is granted the right to the appreciation in the company's share value over a certain period. However, SARs do not provide the employee with actual shares but rather the right to a cash amount equal to the increase in share value.

Advantages of SARs

• No Capital Contribution Needed: Employees do not need to invest their own capital to benefit from the company's share appreciation.
• Benefits from Appreciation: Employees can financially benefit from the rise in share price without actually owning shares.
• Tax Deductible: The company can deduct the costs of a SAR from its profits.

Disadvantages of SARs

• Tax Implications: The payment of SARs may be subject to payroll tax, which can diminish the net benefits.

More information about Stock Appreciation Rights can be found on Rounde.

Comparison between Certificates of Shares and SARs

Key Differences

• Ownership Structure and Control: Certificates of shares do not provide voting rights, while SARs do not provide ownership or control in the company.
• Tax Consequences and Legal Implications: Both instruments have their own tax and legal aspects.

Who Is It Suitable For?

• Certificates of Shares: Ideal for companies looking to attract capital without losing control and for employees who want to benefit from the company's profits. Employees also have the most "skin in the game" since they have to purchase the certificates with their own resources.
• SARs: Suitable for companies that want to reward employees without actually issuing shares and for employees who wish to benefit from the appreciation of shares.

Practical Considerations and Tips

Choosing Process for Companies

When choosing between certificates of shares and SARs, companies should consider various factors, such as the impact on control, administrative burdens, and tax implications. Take our free test to find out which participation form suits your company.

Advice for Employees

Employees should pay close attention to the terms and potential tax consequences of the instruments offered and seek professional advice if necessary.

Seeking Legal and Tax Advice

It is essential to seek legal and tax advice when setting up and managing these schemes to avoid possible complications.

Conclusion

Certificates of shares and Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs) both offer unique advantages for both companies and employees. Certificates of shares help companies attract capital without losing control, while SARs offer employees a financial benefit without ownership of shares. Choosing the right instrument depends on the specific needs and goals of the company.

Appendices and References

• More about Certificates of Shares on Rounde
• More about Stock Appreciation Rights on Rounde