Business Valuation: Essential for Effective Employee Participation

Introduction

Valuation of a business is very important if you want to let employees share in the success of your company. This is called employee participation. Employees can receive shares or options, or participate in a SAR scheme (Stock Appreciation Rights). To do this fairly, you need to know what your company is worth. Otherwise, you won't know how much the shares or options are worth. In this article, we explain why valuation is so important and how you can approach it.

Why is Valuation Important?

A good valuation of your company is important for several reasons. First, it ensures that you can distribute shares or options fairly among your employees. If you don't know what your company is worth, you can't determine how many shares or options you should give. Second, it helps in setting the right price for employee shares. You do not want employees to pay too much or too little. Finally, a good valuation is also important for tax purposes. The tax authorities want to know the value of the shares or options you give to employees.

Free decision aid

There are 6 ways to let employees share in the growth of the company.

Which form suits your company?

Take the decision aid

Methods of Valuation

There are various methods to calculate the value of a business. We will discuss four commonly used methods. Note that an external valuation holds more weight when the tax authorities verify your assessment, compared to a self-assessment.

a. Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) Method

With the DCF method, you look at how much money the company will make in the future. You estimate how much profit the company will generate over the coming years. Then you calculate what that future profit is worth today. This is a popular method because it takes into account the future expectations of the company. The downside is that it can be challenging to accurately estimate future profits.

The tax authorities usually base their assessments on this method.

b. Comparable Companies Method

In this method, you look at other companies that are similar to yours. You find out what those companies are worth and use that as a guideline for your company. This works well if there are many comparable companies. But it can be challenging if your company is very unique or if there is little public information about comparable companies.

c. Asset-based Approach

This method looks at what all the assets of the company are worth. You add together the value of all items, buildings, inventories, and cash in the bank. Then you subtract the debts. What remains is the value of the company. This method is simple but does not account for future growth or the value of trademarks and customers.

d. Earnings Multiple Method

In this method, you multiply the company's earnings by a certain number. This number varies by sector. Below is a table with examples of common multiples for different sectors:

Factors Influencing the Value of a Business

The value of a business depends on many different things. First, financial performance is essential. How much profit does the company make, and how fast is it growing? The market position also plays a role. Is the company a leader in its sector, or are there many competitors? Additionally, we look at growth potential. Does the company have the chance to grow much larger in the future? Finally, intellectual property, such as patents or trademarks, is also valuable for a company.

Valuation for Different Forms of Employee Participation

a. Shares

If you give employees real shares, they need to know what those shares are worth. The value of the company determines the value of each share. For example, if the company is worth 1 million euros and there are 100,000 shares, then each share is worth 10 euros.

b. Share Options

With share options, valuation is also important. The option gives the right to purchase shares in the future at a pre-agreed price. That price is often based on the value of the company at the time the options are granted.

c. Stock Appreciation Rights (SAR)

In a SAR scheme, employees do not receive real shares, but they benefit from the company's value increase. Again, it is crucial to determine the company's value accurately so you can see how much the value has increased.

Challenges in Valuation for Employee Participation

Valuation can be challenging, especially for startups and rapidly growing companies. The value can change quickly. It is also difficult when there is little information about comparable companies, especially if your company is not publicly traded. Finally, the timing of the valuation is important. You do not want employees to be disadvantaged by a temporary dip in the value of the company.

Best Practices for Valuation

There are a few things you can do to make the valuation as accurate as possible. A valuation is necessary when privately selling or buying shares to employees. Because a valuation can be expensive, companies often choose to conduct a valuation once a year. This is also the moment when employees can sell their shares. Additionally, it is important to be open with your employees about how you determine the value. Explain which method you use and why. Finally, it can help to engage an independent expert. They can provide an objective view of your company's value.

Legal and Tax Considerations

When it comes to valuation, you must also consider taxes. The tax authorities will be monitoring the value you assign to your business. If you underestimate the value, you could run into problems, as employees would then be getting shares at a discount. This discount is taxed as income.

Conclusion

A good valuation of your business is crucial for fair and effective employee participation. It helps in the equitable distribution of shares or options and ensures that employees know where they stand. In the future, valuation will likely become even more important, as more companies want to let their employees share in the success.

Want to know more about valuation for your company? Then seek advice from an expert. A good advisor can help you choose the right method and accurately assess the value of your business. We can assist you with this.